Showing posts with label Belief. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Belief. Show all posts

Monday, December 23, 2019

The Mother of the Modern Cathedrals.


Here's the original bridge connecting colosseums and cathedrals.

Who's to say the experience was so different for the individuals and the crowds?

Monday, November 30, 2015

The Evolutionary Tree of Religion

Simon E Davies
Evidently there's something universal and very human about believing in something larger than oneself.

Friday, November 20, 2015

True. True. Truth.


Stay open until you have the whole story.

On complex issues, stay open.

Wednesday, February 4, 2015

Making it to the New York Times.

With the growing public debate springing from the rise of militant atheism, the conversation has turned at least momentarily to some thoughtful consideration of the role that religion in peoples' lives.

I've referred previously to how difficult it is to fashion a coherent set of principles to live by, done one person at a time, and the value of relying on group intelligence in doing so. In a word, re-inventing the wheel is hard work, much of which is done by trial-and-error, which almost by definition means getting burned before we learn.

Now we find the conversation coming from David Brooks, writing in the New York Times, an august publication if ever there was one.

Brooks suggests that if non-religious people want to be taken seriously, they will need to move beyond spelling out the limits of religious belief, into the realm of positive actions on behalf of their own lifestyle. It's one thing to espouse freedom from the constraints of organized thinking, to champion individual choice. It's quite another to admit the challenges a person faces if this is a priority.

Consider the tasks a person would have to perform, he says, to live secularism well:
•Secular individuals have to build their own moral philosophies. Religious people inherit creeds that have evolved over centuries. Autonomous secular people are called upon to settle on their own individual sacred convictions.

•Secular individuals have to build their own communities. Religions come equipped with covenantal rituals that bind people together, sacred practices that are beyond individual choice. Secular people have to choose their own communities and come up with their own practices to make them meaningful.

•Secular individuals have to build their own Sabbaths. Religious people are commanded to drop worldly concerns. Secular people have to create their own set times for when to pull back and reflect on spiritual matters.

•Secular people have to fashion their own moral motivation. It’s not enough to want to be a decent person. You have to be powerfully motivated to behave well. Religious people are motivated by their love for God and their fervent desire to please Him. Secularists have to come up with their own powerful drive that will compel sacrifice and service.
A common thread here is the vastness of such challenges. Undertaken individually, one person at a time, it's clear that is simply isn't going to happen. How many people actually have the time, the energy, the sheer capacity to even think about these things? Much less to sustain the efforts over an entire lifetime?
As I've written,
Building and maintaining a Belief System is a complex and energy-intensive proposition. It's one of the crucial elements of being human that is best done as a group. But group problem solving takes time as well.
Living secularism well, is the question. Well by whose definition? Perhaps those who aggressively deride the religiously oriented life have a totally different set of expectations for themselves.

That is, after all, the purpose of asserting one's individual right to believe as one wishes.

Monday, December 1, 2014

One Approach to Managing Beliefs.

 “The mission of Avatar® in the world is to catalyze the integration of belief systems. When we perceive that the only difference between us is our beliefs and that beliefs can be created or discreated with ease, the right and wrong game will wind down, a co-create game will unfold, and world peace will ensue.”
–Harry Palmer

The Avatar Course, created by Harry Palmer, thus focuses in its descriptive materials on the importance of stepping back from one's belief systems, monitoring, consciously choosing them based on life goals. On first blush, to a scholar interested in the role of belief systems in an unfolding life this is a concept worthy of further investigation.

Aiming the materials at "world peace" hints at other levels beyond personal belief systems, and a quick web search reveals information about Avatar as a large-group awareness training--LGAT--suggesting caution in looking too deeply into it as a source of credible thoughts on human development and behavior. I've been around long enough to have experienced and observed these trainings and well know their methodologies and underlying philosophies.

As it turns out--bless the miracles of connected communication--Harry Palmer and the Avatar Course are also worthy of a Wikipedia page, where the history of the organization is linked directly and unquestionably to the world of Scientology. Aside from its controversial standing in contemporary culture, most people would agree that the Church of Scientology, as it has identified itself, is clearly an organization devoted to beliefs and practices.

We wind up here bumping head-on into a quandary I find myself pondering fairly often: what does one do with beliefs about Belief Systems, without being blinded by those beliefs?

It's a personal issue for me as I explore ideas in this journal.

And there is more--or less--to Mr Palmer than he presents in his Avatar Course materials.

Of course, the only way to learn about the materials in the Avatar Course is to take the course. While there are published materials about the course, those materials are explicit in their requirement of confidentiality for what the course actually contains:
There are a number of simple reasons why parts of the Avatar materials are kept confidential, but the most important reason requires some explanation.
Avatar is much more than a philosophy, as any student who has experienced its transmission from a licensed Master will quickly tell you. There are word-lessons, and there are world-lessons. A word-lesson is someone’s attempt to convey his experience to another via spoken or written symbols.
A world-lesson is something that a person lives through. It’s something he actually confronts and copes with in life, and from the world-lesson he emerges changed...more experienced...bigger! A word-lesson very rarely produces such a result.
A world-lesson is a unique personal experience; it does not require translation into symbols or sounds to be understood. It is involvement in, and observation, of events as they occur.
Avatar is both a word-lesson and a world-lesson. It is a word-lesson only for the purpose of introducing students to their own personal world-lessons. The word-lessons that Avatar conveys are insignificant compared to the world-lessons it opens to students.
The Avatar Course requires a well-trained and disciplined Avatar Master to ensure that the Avatar techniques make it off the page and into life. Avatar becomes valuable when it is conveyed as a world-lesson on how to assimilate world-lessons.
By keeping the Avatar materials confidential and permitting their teaching only by those trained to transmit them properly, each person receives his or her own unique world-lesson from the Avatar experience.
And of course the only way to experience these world-lessons is in an LGAT. For fees that are intentionally, purposely, set at a high level.

While I find it somehow strangely reassuring to know others are looking at beliefs about Belief Systems, I'll pass on further explorations of this particular avenue

Saturday, October 11, 2014

Scripture and belief.







There is a fundamental misunderstanding among these critics of religion in that they believe, first and foremost, that people get their values, their morals from their scripture, when in reality the exact opposite is true. You bring your morals and your values to the scriptures; you don’t extract them from them. You learn that on day one of the study of religion — day one, that’s the first thing that you learn!

Monday, May 12, 2014

The Death of God. Again.


The short version: God and Religion are not the same thing.
__________________________
Here we go again.

Serious people are writing about the death of God in an Of Course kind of way.

We all know, they seem to say, that God is dead. Now what do we do?

Such is the tone of Alasdair Craig in a recent issue of the British magazine Prospect, in a thoughtful look at two recently published books, with references to several others.

The title of the essay says it all: God is dead--What next?

Craig's thesis accepts the value of religious belief in human life, one of giving meaning and purpose. Equating the existence of God with this value, with particular emphasis on the personal and intimate vision of God the Father posited by Christianity, he wonders how the impersonal world of scientific thought can replace such an important human institution.

His alternative to religious belief appears to be art and literature, though he recognizes the lack of overall narrative in these endeavors that will leave them shallow by comparison with the Quest story inherent in religion, which flows through time from creation to after-life. Quoting the author of one of the books under review, he notes that the popular atheism
comes at the “enormous price” of “renouncing depth.” Little wonder, he implies, that its dismal art is so at home in the shallow worlds of “fashion and design, the media and public relations, advertising agencies and recording studios.”
In other words, the art of atheism finds comfort in the service of the world of commerce.

I don't think we're talking about the death of God here. Not at all. We're talking about the death of Religion. Survey data continue to show that few people profess to be atheists or even agnostics. Most people in the western world continue to have some deep sense of something more powerful in their lives than their own meager minds and selves can comprehend.

Mr Craig and the authors he is studying are omitting the most important question of all: what experience underlies, drives, the need for religious belief? In an historical sense, what needs have art and history addressed so well for the course of human civilization?

To put it as succinctly as I can at the moment, the core question has something to do with whether we understand ourselves to be something more than human to begin with. Where I've come to in my own explorations so far is that we are at core not humans seeking spiritual experiences: we are Spiritual Beings presently engaged in Human Experiences. We all have some deep and unspoken memory of being a part of some vastness, and we are searching for a connection to that mystery.

We simply have lost our ability to come together in a coherent way to tell and retell the story of what that vastness may be or may mean. We know intuitively that our birth and our death have some connection to where we are. We want desperately to hold on to our deep memories.

And our institutions have failed us, floundered on the shores of human venality. Based as they were on primitive levels of education, short and brutal lives (with limited accumulations of experience), few and simple communication technologies, restricted contact with alternative institutions, they have proven inadequate to the task of providing plausible comfort and support to a searching humanity.

Paradoxically, the blessings of long life, communication beyond human imagination, education and resources for the millions, we wind up alone with God while we await the slowly developing group consciousness to carry us forward. God is still there. Most of us recognize something larger than ourselves in the universe. We simply have no way of systematically finding contact with that Something Larger.

Building and maintaining a Belief System is a complex and energy-intensive proposition. It's one of the crucial elements of being human that is best done as a group. But group problem solving takes time as well.

As a culture we are between worlds. The old one no longer fits. The new one is still forming.







Thursday, May 1, 2014

Belief: Navigation System.

The only thing missing here is a time-keeping element.
In my explorations and my thinking about the function of Belief in people's lives, I've variously referred to it as a compass, then a gyroscope.

As my more careful studies continue to develop, I'm recognizing that having a compass is of no point unless you have a map. When I've said compass I've assumed the existence of a map. Silly me. The map is the necessary element. What does the immediate terrain look like? Where are you going? What ways are available for you to get there? Where are you right now?

Morning ritual.
This morning over grapefruit Claudia and I were continuing our conversation about a film series we're watching on Tuesday evenings with a study group at our mountain church. We've just watched week five of a six-episode series called Time of Death, produced for Showtime. Claudia observed that the people who appear to have the most comfort, the least anxiety, with their end times seem to have some set of beliefs that guide them. Imagine me perking up with a comment like that!

We continued our conversation long enough for her to examine where she was going, but I admit that for a few minutes I was less focused on her comments as I struggled to contain my Aha! moment, put enough flesh on it to come back to it.

Aha! We take comfort from our beliefs. They give us a sense of where we are, where we're going, how we might get there. Some predictability in a vastly unpredictable world, exploring totally new territory by reference to familiar methods and signposts.

That's when I realized we're talking Navigation System, not compass. Not a single piece of technology, essential as it might be, but an entire set of related elements that interact with each over time, with a history and a future.

I know a bit about systems.

In fact, I've referred to Belief Systems. Mostly I had in mind at the time something closer to the System we call Religion. Related, with differences and similarities yet to be explored, is an individual's personal Belief System.

Accurate map, reference points available for physical  verification and validation, compass/gyroscope, dividers, straight edge, pencil, historic record--all the pieces, interlocking, serving each other, operating to maintain itself, requiring input and producing output, in a self-balancing way.

And so I arrive at another point of reference in my own scheme of managing my own existence on this planet: maps and geography are a central element in my life.

Space. And Time.
Our family clock. Past, present, future.

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

Sustaining Belief: Confirmation Bias.


Now we move into a bit of technical area, with a good description of the way science is studying how belief systems are maintained. At first glimpse it seems science is adding only labels to the conversation, but on deeper thought what these labels signify is that there is a body of careful study going on in the field. From that it's probably fair to say that over the years there's been some good understanding developed of the dynamics and the parameters involved.

Michael Eades is a physician whose writings I have followed for 15 years or more, an earlier adopter and advocate of the notion that carbohydrates are problematic in human nutrition. "Early adopter" in a field like this is a polite way of saying Rebel and Damned Proud of It, and I felt fortunate to find his carefully reasoned, well-documented and human-friendly writing when I did. I continue to subscribe to his blog, where he writes about Nutritional science and anything else that strikes my fancy. I am not, by the way, happy to see that he has followed the medical model of hawking supplements over the internet. Talk about cheesy.

The term researchers have come to use for selective attention and validation in maintaining belief systems is Confirmation Bias. Dr Eades:
To show how the confirmation bias is built brick by brick, let us turn to politics.
[Let's] Assume we come to politics a tabula rasa, starting at zero.
Imagine yourself at the very top of the pyramid of knowledge and belief. Right at the apex, there is no knowledge or belief. You are a political newborn, so to speak.
At the base of the pyramid, the knowledge level is deep and wide. On the right side of the base is where all the conservative ideals, knowledge, and insights lie. On the left side live the liberal ones.
When you start at the top, you get tipped down one side or another. Maybe it’s a column you read, or a talking head on TV, or a parent, teacher, or friend. Doesn’t really matter, but somehow you get tipped to one side or the other and start rolling down that side of the pyramid, gathering ideology as you go.
You establish your rudimentary political views, and, as you start rolling down, you read more, you engage in discussion, you watch cable channels that mirror your views, and you, in general, become more entrenched in your ideology. All the way down you continue to confirm your ever-growing bias. Once you have reached the bottom, you have marinated so long in your particular political sauce that you can’t possibly understand how anyone could not believe the same way you do. In fact, you are certain that anyone who doesn’t is a completely misguided idiot.
It never occurs to you that others may have tipped and rolled down the other side of the pyramid. They, too, have reached their side of the bottom and are completely infused with the righteousness of their own beliefs and cannot imagine how someone could be so stupid as to believe any differently.
What is even worse is that many of us who have rolled down our own side of the pyramid refuse to even read anything written by one who has rolled down the other side. You don’t want to learn anything that might throw you into cognitive dissonance, so you renounce it as trash, unworthy of your reading, and move on. We’ve all done this at some time or other.
We work hard never to let opposing views penetrate our consciousness in an effort to avoid the unpleasant sensation of cognitive dissonance. The confirmation bias is the tool we use.
If I were writing this I'd eliminate the implication that somehow this is a problem process. He writes this way because he's had an unpleasant encounter with a correspondent who exhibited arrogant confirmation bias.

He is also an important contributor in a field that has been simply overrun with what appears to be an abuse of a belief system for political and financial gain, the field of human nutrition.

But I hasten to add that belief systems represent an invaluable process that enables us to maintain our sense of balance and direction in a chaotic world.







Our beliefs are the operating system of the psychic and spiritual gyroscope. They keep us going even in the face of challenges.


I'll finish this posting with a quote that takes us back to Religion. Belief. Cosmos.

Saturday, April 5, 2014

Belief: Holding steady in a storm.


A belief system serves an essential purpose, supporting our efforts at going in a purposeful direction in the midst of life's storms. It's designed to withstand buffeting, and we can thank God for that. Every system has its gyroscope. In the human psychic system, that is the set of interlocking, interacting beliefs.

A belief is a working hypothesis, a conclusion based on experience to this point in time. We can adopt an As If attitude to use as a guide for planning and anticipating, yet still stay open to new learning as experiences continue to come in. In which case we adopt new beliefs to use in navigation.

Because the terrain we are navigating is ever-emerging, our belief system requires calibration, maintenance and systematic recalibration. It becomes useless and dangerous when it is outmoded, incomplete, improperly set.

There may be one True North, but a useful navigation system includes a growing and evolving map of the local terrain as well as of the far destinations.

Monday, March 31, 2014

Where is truth?

                                           
                                           Do not seek the truth.
                                           Only cease to cherish opinion.
Chien-chih Seng-ts-an
Third Zen Patriarch
606AD


The Great Way is not difficult
for those who have no preferences.

Sunday, March 30, 2014

Francis Bennett: I Am That I Am.

I have a body, but I am not that body.

Who am I?

One of the fruits of the discipline of meditation I have practiced since my young adult life has been a clear and distinct awareness of this I, as a separate level of existence from all else in my world.

Though at an ego level am familiar with this I, comfortable with this I, reassured by the presence of this I, what Ego has never done is become conscious of the many layers and qualities this I possesses.

David Ford, my friend, neighbor and fellow parishioner at our little mountain church, has introduced me to the work of Francis Bennett.

Bennett, a Roman Catholic on a lifetime journey of discovery that has taken him in and out of a plethora of spiritual traditions, has prepared a memoir of his learnings about the I in him. Appropriately enough, the tile of his book is I Am That I Am.


Over and again in reading Bennett's journal I recognized the similarity of his experience with my own, the familiar descriptions of experiences I have had but never verbalized. Throughout my life journey this recognition has been a signal to me that I am in the presence of something genuine, eternal and universal.

And yet in reading these pages I've found myself alternating between enjoyment and impatience. I particularly appreciate the stories he tells, recounting in first person what his actual experience was. Less valuable are his attempts at generalizing, theorizing, interpreting, comparing. When he comes to exploring parallels between his experiences and the words in the New Testament about the supposed teachings of Jesus, he loses me. My present understanding of the socio-political history of these writings prevents me from considering them an authority on much of anything, and it feels like a waste of energy to look for meanings. They had their purposes in history, and that's all I'll say about it here.

In reading Bro Bennett's writings I also grow impatient with the limitations of human language, and his attempts to use it, in explicating this most mysterious of experiences. Analysis falls short, feels false. This is not a statement about the author. It's a comment on the ethereal, and on the smallness of the human mind and the feeble results of filtering this level of reality through such a clearly restricted and restrained transmission channel.

This is one piece of the puzzle, the vast elephant. Bro Bennett is one blind person, describing as best he can a vast, infinite experience.

I begin this exploration from the ground of my own experience. I know who this I is. I want to learn Who this I is.

Considering these writings in light of Hesse's Siddhartha and his life brings me one step closer to wholeness. 

Adding in the experience of Beauty, and the possibility of consciously allowing myself to explore that element of this world, I may be able to continue my journey.

Friday, March 21, 2014

Remaining open.


Each person in a complex system has a different perception, with countless interpretations.

The more interpretations we gather, the easier it becomes to gain a sense of the whole.

Our seemingly separate lives become meaningful as we discover how truly necessary we are to each other.

It starts with the earth.

Driving into our high mountain plateau, one is first struck by the monoliths. Granite outcroppings dot the valleys and canyons, erupting lik...